Trump’s Foreign Policy Act I: Kill a Chicken to Scare Monkeys

Helen Raleigh,

“To kill a chicken to scare monkeys” is a famous Chinese military strategy, and is often attributed to one of the greatest military strategists who ever lived, Sun Tzu, author of the famous treatise, The Art of War. This particular strategy is designed to send a message (often a warning) to powerful enemies by attacking a smaller, weaker power first.  I don’t know if Trump, the author of The Art of The Deal, ever read The Art of War, but his surprising air strike on Syria on April 6th, 2017, clearly achieved a similar effect to this ancient strategy.

Many political pundits worried that the air strike is a prelude to the U.S. deepening its involvement in the war with the Assad regime. I think they miss the point. If Trump’s intention is to go to war with Assad, he could have waited until Chinese president Xi left Mar-a-Lago.  Instead, he chose to strike Assad on the eve of the much hyped summit with Xi. The timing of the strike didn’t seem like a coincidence. While the target of air strike was Syria (the “chicken”), the underline message was intended for China and its client state, North Korea (the “Monkeys”). Trump had every intention to give the Xi a front seat to witness America’s military might and his own willingness to take swift and decisive actions alone. Unlike President Obama, Trump made it loud and clear that he’s nobody’s pushover.

Another curious thing Trump did on the same evening was to leave Xi alone right after state dinner and hold a press conference on the air strike in Syria. Xi and the Chinese delegates most likely view Trump’s action as a perceived slight. High level political events such as this are usually highly scripted and full of protocols.  One of Xi’s ultimate personal visions is to return China to its former glory as a super power in the world.  As the world’s second largest economy, many in China, probably including Xi, believe that China has already achieved such superpower status and therefore, China should be treated as America’s equal with respect. Trump, on the other hand, by taking care of business in Syria while meeting Xi, probably was sending his Chinese guest a not so subtle hint that the U.S. – China relationship isn’t his highest priority. 

trumpaction_small Trump's Foreign Policy Act I: Kill a Chicken to Scare Monkeys Foreign Policy

During his press conference, Trump called on “all civilized nations to join us in seeking to end the slaughter and bloodshed in Syria.” President Xi was curiously silent on the whole matter. He missed a great opportunity to act like a global leader. If he believes that it’s China’s rightful place to be a superpower, he has to remember that, as Uncle Ben told Spiderman, “with great power comes great responsibility.” China can’t just have all the prestige of being a super power while taking no stands against any rouge regime in the name of non-intervention in other nation’s “domestic affairs.”

Prior to the Trump-Xi summit, many Chinese leaders, perhaps including Xi, viewed Trump as merely a business man who knew little about international politics. Therefore, Xi was most likely prepared to stroke Trump’s ego by announcing a few economic deals which would bring more Chinese investment to the U.S. and create more jobs for Americans. That fact that no such deal was announced at the end of the summit signals to me that the Xi perhaps recognized that he might have underestimated Trump and his original offer would be inadequate.

It’s too early to judge whether Trump’s message to China achieved its full impact. I don’t think President Xi is scared. Just like Trump, Xi himself is a strong man, and he appreciates and respects another strong man. Chinese leaders are known for their pragmatism. Xi is no exception. There are already hints of China adjusting its strategic thinking toward the U.S. For example, China has been often quick to criticize unilateral military actions by the U.S. in the past,. But this time, China’s reaction has been much more muted.  The day after US’s air strike in Syria, China’s Xinhua news site, a mouth piece of the Chinese government, reported that China condemns the chemical attack in Syria without taking any position on the U.S. air strike. Another headline from the same site said it all-“Xi says ready to boost China-U.S. ties from new starting point with Trump.”

|